You cannot safely run a 12,5:1 engine on 91-93 oct pump gas unless you drive it real easy, the car has excellent cooling, you drive in places were it's not too hot in the summer and, perhaps, you make the spark curve not so aggressive.
To run 12.5:1 on the street and keep the engine out of detonation you'll need to mix about 1:2 91-93-oct pump gas with 100-oct unleaded race gas or 1:1 91-93-oct with 110-oct leaded race gas.
That said, if this engine is only going to be used to go to shows and you're not going to run it hard, you probably can get by with much less of a percentage of race gas, say 2:1 pump 91-93 and 100 unleaded.
Switching to 10 or 10.5:1 compression will allow you to run 91-93 oct pump gas will little or no problems.
Will that decrease the value of the car?
I'm not an expert on the issue, but I'd guess since the car is not an original L88 to begin with, there will be little or no impact on the value of the car if you rebuild the motor with 10:1 compression.