Ray,
You know that I am a fan of Gelcoat, and have used it many times. There is absolutely no downside to Gelcoat if you discount the additional labor. In my opinion, there is nothing that seals old repairs and consolidates spiderweb cracks like gelcoat. That being said, the stuff is a pain to sand and will sustantially will add to the labor bill if you are paying to have the work done.
I hear the mantra constantly repeated the it was not used originally, so why use it. The same can be said for high-build primer, surfacers, basecoat/clearcoat, or single stage paints! Many people will suggest the use of Slicksand, Featherfill, or any number of similar polyester primer surfacers, and that is fine, I use them as well, but I use them after Gelcoat!
Gelcoat is nothing but polyester resin with a wax that forms a cure membrane after spraying. The body panels of a Corvette are nothing but polyester resin impregnated into fiberglass mat. You entire body is made out of the same material! Most of the high-build primer surfacers are made out of exactly the same resin. The only difference is that these surfacers also have a large content of inert material that allows high-build and easy sanding. Even body filler is the same material, it just has a higher level of inert material in it. You can really look at a high build primer surfacer as a sprayable form of body filler! All of these products are made of exactly the same resin that is used to make the body panels on your car, and the only difference is the lack of glass mat and the percentage content of inert material.
Gelcoat is not easy sanding, it as a wax layer which clogs sand paper until it is sanded off and even after it is sanded it is a lot harder than Featherfill or one of the other surfacers. You only have to strip a car that has been gelcoated to see the difference, the car with gelcoat will strip right down to the gelcoat and then stop there, ( unless the stripper is left on way too long) but a car that has been done with the polyester surfacer will have the surfacer attacked and quite probably the body filler underneath. This because that the inert material that allows the surfacer to be sanded easily, also makes it porus like a sponge, and it will be penetrated by the stripper. If you are sealing old repairs from solvent swelling, which material would you rather have on your car, the one whick is almost impervious to solvents, or the one that will absorb the solvent?
There are many, many, cars painted every year without gelcoat, and they will, for the most part, perform very well. To me there is a distinct advantage to gelcoat, and my labor is free, so I use it. If I was paying for my paint work, I might be less inclined to use it with the additional costs associated with it, but probably would still use it. The fact that the PPG guys reccomend it's usage on fiberglass bodies should speak volumes. They know that there is nothing better for sealing down repairs and spiderweb cracks. Just my $.02 for what it is worth.
Regards, John McGraw