The tire issue will never go away as the companies keep upgrading their product. I just returned from the National Corvette Museum's Hall of Fame activity and drove 2600 miles in my 02 Coupe. I had previously driven it to the NCM on the Goodyear OEM tires and also the CF in Cleveland and got between 32 and 34 mpg. Last year I put Michelin All Season tires on the coupe; Michelin warrants the tire for 40K miles. My mileage dropped to 26 to 28 mpg at the recommended pressure of 30 psi cold. On the return trip, I aired up the tires to 33 psi on the Kansas Turnpike just outside of Topeka. Got 29+ mpg, still not what I expected. So as this thread suggests, if you want performance, go with GY Super tires. Otherwise choose the tire on the way you expect to use them, then set the price you want to pay. I am pleased with the Michelin A/S run flat tires, but next year I will drive my 08 vert that got 32 mpg on the round trip from CF in Effingham this year on the OEM GY tires. Tires and pressure do make a difference especially on long trips where mpg is important.
Barrett