Welcome to the Corvette Forums at the Corvette Action Center!

The Asphalt Jungle: Corvette ZR1 -- What You Don't Get for Almost $120,000

Rob

Site Administrator
Staff member
Administrator
Joined
Sep 16, 2000
Messages
13,962
Location
New Hampshire
Corvette
1990 Corvette ZR-1
The Asphalt Jungle: Corvette ZR1 -- What You Don't Get for Almost $120,000

By Arthur St. Antoine
Motor Trend Magazine

The new Chevrolet Corvette ZR1 is a Krakatoa eruption encased in aluminum and carbon fiber, so powerful, so fast, so impatient along any horizontal axis to warp your precious pink guttiwuts into tofu, you almost don't know whether to dash for the driver's seat or the men's room. Recently, the ZR1 took on the world's sports-car elite -- Ferrari 599 GTB, Porsche GT2, Nissan GT-R -- and leaves them all choking in the gaseous offal of its supercharged humiliation foundry.

Yet while the ZR1's capacity for reducing test gear to tears may earn it the mantle "King of the Hill," in most driving situations it's more like a precocious prince. Kings are august. Their rough edges have been honed away by fastidious breeding, seemingly limitless monetary support, and time passed in the most privileged of corridors. Moreover, true kings walk, act, and talk like kings. Thus, it's not without cause that the Ferrari and the Porsche command such kingly sums-especially in comparison with the brash bolide from Bowling Green. The driving experience they offer is simply unmatched by the ZR1.

Part of it lies in the driver interface. To board the Ferrari is to immerse oneself in the come-hither aroma of hides from bovines obviously fed a steady diet of tagliolini con funghi and Chanel No5. Your eyes transfix on voluptuous ellipses of carbon fiber, on aluminum pedals drilled into modern art pieces, on a Formula 1-bred steering wheel that costs as much as a good motorcycle. The Porsche is more formal, more starched-business shirt, but no less evocative. A mere touch of the Alcantara-wrapped wheel or shift lever fires the word "special" deep into your cerebellum. The sport seats restrain you like a wise mentor. Pieces fit as if the entire cabin were milled from a single billet of good taste.

In contrast, the ZR1's cockpit smells like a glue factory. The leather radiates a mass-production gloss. The steering wheel: plucked straight from a pedestrian Chevy Malibu. None of this diminishes the ZR1's prowess; it merely highlights that the 599 and the GT2 offer something more.

Other, more-intangible virtues surface when you take Ferrari or Porsche for a run. There is no denying (or escaping) the aristocratic exceptionalness of these cars. Their engines-the 599's naturally aspirated V-12, the GT2's turbocharged flat-six-crackle and effervesce from idle to redline. Never for a moment do you forget you're piloting a special machine. In comparison, the ZR1's V-8 (and the GT-R's turbo-six, for that matter) rises out of the ordinary only at full-bore. Like the most charismatic of movie idols, Ferrari and Porsche own whatever space they enter, whenever they enter it. The spotlight they perform under never switches off.

By now, the haters are undoubtedly reaching for their crayons. "St. Antoine you ignerent snob! The ZR1 blows those crappy Euro weenies out of the water!!" Ah, clearly, this crowd wishes to wade into profound discussions of empiricism and methodology. What, that is to say, is the definition of "better?" Is rock band A better than rock band B because it plays louder? Is one teacher better than another because he can speak more quickly?

The ZR1 deserves its spot at the top of this month's comparison. Its staggering performance results and huge price advantage (compared with the supercar elites) cannot be ignored. Given a free choice of keys for the weekend, though, almost all of you would bolt for the 599 or the GT2.

And I wouldn't blame you. The ZR1 is a sensationally fast car. The Ferrari and the Porsche are crowning achievements.
 
Perhaps a better title would have been:

“What you get for an extra $72,000 to $182,000?

With the GT2 at $192k and the Ferrari at $302k for the 2008 models, you will certainly get what you pay for if a higher quality interior is your goal. If total performance is the requirement, you can go with the bargain basement Corvette.
 
What gets me about writers who churn out such rhetoric is that they cannot afford any of the elite cars they write about so such dissertations can be taken as their form of verbal masturbation over an object they will have little to no relationship with.

I would suspect that his only relationship with any of the cars he has mentioned probably happened at one of the International auto shows currently touring the country. Considering what these writers make per year, this writer is probably driving something between a 20 year old Subaru or new Prius and dreaming about the day he is invited to drive any of these cars. Owning one is his personal fantasy. Look for stains on his cars seats.:puke

Denny
 
The way I see it, GM had a price point they had to meet when designing the ZR1. In order to meet that price point, GM made the decision and put their resources into developing a world class Ferrari beating car. The trade-off from that decision is that the King is equipped with an interior that is not on par with the likes of the 300k 599GTB.

Was it the right decision? FWIW, I think it was.

:v Jason
 
Such narrowly focused articles such as this grind on me quite a bit. I’m not sure what to think about such writers other than to think they are idiots. But surely that cannot be the case. I do think their comparisons are rather absurd. Why not compare apples to apples. Find another vehicle in the same price range and do a similar comparison. If not then I have numerous custom built specialty cars with interiors that put the Ferrari to shame but is that a fair comparison?? I would be asking if the Corvette can provide so much and such reliability for $100K why does Ferrari have to charge so much for their vehicle. At two to three times the price of a Vette it is very overpriced. At that point you realize that the Ferrari’s price is a status symbol for those who need such to fill a void in their self esteem. While I have and do know a few Ferrari owners who are sociable it seems that most others are rather pretentious. I am not talking about the collector who is involved with vintage Ferrari’s. They are a breed unto themselves.

In the real world the Ferrari requires more intensive maintenance to maintain the factory delivered performance level. That nice leather does not hold up well in the Arizona sun. If you own one you need to have a second car to drive when the Ferrari is in the shops for one of those extended services intervals. Yes, along with other exotics, we do have a fair number of them wandering around in the Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, Arizona area however they are not daily drivers. While there might be one or two out there, I have never seen a ten year old Ferrari that has over 100K miles.

As a side note, I recently found out that my Magna motorcycle uses the same spark plugs as a Ferrari. If I walk into a NAPA dealer to order Magna spark plugs they do not have a listing for my motorcycle however if I walk in and ask for spark plugs for my Ferrari they usually have them on the shelf or in their warehouse. I love telling them I have a four cylinder Ferrari and only need four plugs.:boogie

Enjoy the ride,
Denny
 

Corvette Forums

Not a member of the Corvette Action Center?  Join now!  It's free!

Help support the Corvette Action Center!

Supporting Vendors

Dealers:

MacMulkin Chevrolet - The Second Largest Corvette Dealer in the Country!

Advertise with the Corvette Action Center!

Double Your Chances!

Our Partners

Back
Top Bottom