Welcome to the Corvette Forums at the Corvette Action Center!

After market Lexan tops....

Bluemill

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 20, 2005
Messages
107
Location
Scituate, MA
Corvette
2000 Navy targa
Anybody care to comment on the Melrose International acryllic targa tops vs. Thompson Astro Tops? Or, are their product reviews for these two manufacturers on this or another site? The Italian 33 fix does not work for my top, so I have to buy a new one.

Thanks,

Bluemill

:bash
 
Anybody care to comment on the Melrose International acryllic targa tops vs. Thompson Astro Tops? Or, are their product reviews for these two manufacturers on this or another site? The Italian 33 fix does not work for my top, so I have to buy a new one.

Thanks,

Bluemill

:bash
Whats the Italian 33 Fix??:confused
I repair and refurbish Lexan tops all the time with good success,depending the problem!:thumb
Got any photos??;shrug
 
What did you end up doing? My C4 has an Astro top that I found to be half way unglued. It must of been like this since I bought it as I remember someone commenting years ago about the top making noise. I just thought it was the usual rattles. Found out recently half the glass was seperated.
 
My new top...

Well, I didn't get a lot of responses from this site, Corvette Forum, or Corvette Mechanic, but I knew I had to do something because the top looked like hell, and I plan on keeping my car for a good long while.

Without any major recommendations on any one product, I figured I would involve one of the tried and true Corvette parts accessories houses. From my price and product description cross references I had a hunch that both Zip and Mid America were using the same vendor, and if anything was bogus about the product, I was confident that either of those companies would make it right. Specifically, the refurbished or remanufactured top was what I decided on , through Zip, because their price was slightly better, and they included shipping for the core roof frame. $800.00 net after getting your $500 core back.

All was done very promptly, like 2 1/2 weeks, and I didn't even have to chase my core credit, it came back fast! The quality is excellent, and I would challenge a Bloomington Gold Judge to say that it was a remake.
Nice big fat new weather strips that take out all of the "ThwacK" rattle on the windshield header when you go over stiff bumps- when the strips get all compressed. I guess if your frame is cracked or seriously damaged you are screwed, but that was not my issue.

I even got a call from the owner of the company that did the work! He was very informaitive. He said the problem causing the delamination or crazing was too much heat, and that regardless of the age of your top, you must keep your windows down a crack to keep air circulating to keep the temp down. The factory top is really two components, formed together, first a harder, glass like top surface, and then the usual much softer lexan/polymer base. I think he said the forming temperature is like 145-160 degrees, temperatures easily obtainable in the summer if your car is left to cook all day in the sun with the windows all the way up. This happened to me last summer in New England, we had a very hot spell, and I got lazy about putting the car in the shade.

All of a sudden I started seeing from the inside, side to side striations, running through the top, like hundreds of parallel spyder web like lines in the plastic. The key, leave the window down a half an inch, or even a quarter, if you can't park it in the shade. The other issue was the obvious delamination of the two components on the outside, starting, from what is typical, the passenger side- rear.

I worked like a dog, the better part of my summer vacation trying to sand out the problem, got bales of wet or dry paper, bought a sander, etc. and only roughed out about 14" through the VERY TOUGH glass layer. I had spent about 40 hours on it at this point. It was the slowest progress I have ever encountered in all my years of working on cars, I just wasn't getting anywhere, and wasn't sure if I was going to like it when I got done with all the effort!

I am totally satisfied with the route I took. The quality is like new, but at a $4-500 savings vs. GM OEM.

Enjoy,

Bluemill
 
That's good infomation Bluemill, thanks for sharing. I have just started to notice similar crazing on my top. I've been tossing around a couple of options and I think I'm going to get an OEM replacement as I want a painted roof. I wear a hat when I drive to protect the hole in my haircut, rarely even notice that my roof is clear.
Cheers
 
Top make..

I thought that this was a Melrose before taking delivery, and talking with the owner of the company, who was on the west coast, far away from Melrose. The price was the same for the top from Melrose direct, as was the price of getting it through Zip, AND with the comfort and convenience of having Zip standing behind its product.

They did not advertise their name, nor did Zip. On some of the packaging it did say Zip. They are a solid outfit in my opinion.
 
refurb Tops

I do not recall a lifetime warranty. I only had one respondent out of about 6 inquiries to this website, Corvette Mechanic, or Corvette Forum who even brought up Melrose. I had an equal number (1) who recommended Astro tops. It seems most people just buy the OEM. I refused to do so becuase the product should not have done this in the first place, and I wasn't going to pay them a huge amount AGAIN for poor quality.

When I say delamination, I am refrring to just the separation of the hard glass coating from the polymer base, which is an ugly cosmetic issue, not a safety one like the two main pieces separating.

I'm happy with what I've got. It's very tight and quiet, and looks just like a new one. Only time will tell if it's any better than OEM.

Best,

Bluemill
 

Corvette Forums

Not a member of the Corvette Action Center?  Join now!  It's free!

Help support the Corvette Action Center!

Supporting Vendors

Dealers:

MacMulkin Chevrolet - The Second Largest Corvette Dealer in the Country!

Advertise with the Corvette Action Center!

Double Your Chances!

Our Partners

Back
Top Bottom