please spare me the sales pitch for an insurance product that we have discussed over and over as not being most appropriate for a collector car - as I tell MY FRIENDS HERE, you want a policy that provides coverage on an Agreed-Value basis, and pays you for a total loss on such a basis. I am fairly confident your "good hands" reference does not provide THAT coverage. . . . .
As for the original poster - I have an agreed value of $40K on my 65, with HAggerty for $300 and change, annual premium. I am 41 with a clean record, now anyway.
ps. I am a lawyer for a group of insurnace companies that provide the sort of coverage that you would get from the good hands people, and not the kind of coverage that you get from Haggerty, Grundy, etc. - so I have no motive to provide this sort of advice other than it is just what is right for my fellows here . . . .