The Problem with the edelbrock carbs , well over here in South Africa that is , is that most imported units are designed for lean running , so you have to buy one of the calibration kits for it , and once you have used whatever spring , needle and jets you want , and you need to tune another - you need to buy another calibration kit (we cant get loose components here) . I have tried to adjust off idle stumbles in many edelbrocks using the pump lever hole method , changing rod springs , jets and needles and eventually just changed to a Holley and fixed it. Float level adjustment on an Edelbrock is also not that great , Far easier on a holley to do that and to change jets.
At any rate , the holley is much more adjustable on the acceleration circuit , you can change shooters , pump volumes and pump cams and power valve so can fine tune the off idle characteristics far better then the Edelbrock. I would NEVER buy one of those non adjustable Holleys anyway.
I suppose its horses for courses , but most performace v8's running here run Holleys , I have had some success with Edelbrocks , my mildly modified el Camino (actually a holden) with a 350 runs a 600 Edelbrock that worked perfectly out the box.
One of the problems I have had with holleys , especially those "remaufactured" ones is porosity or warpage of the metering blocks.