Try2pas, are you a sporting driver? Or just a casual burble around town with the occasional jab at the throttle? If you're the latter, stick with 15's and BFG T/A's.
If you want to start getting a more planted feel to the road and feel like you can actually take a corner at speed, you need to go to 17" rims. Your tire choices become much much greater across the board. I was concerned with going to 17's and losing the white letters. I can tell you now that I don't miss them given the level of performance I gained by going to 17's. Function over fashion. (I also didn't like that the BFG's have a speed rating of "S", which signifies 112mph).
Summit Racing (.com) has the BFG's and two other brands in a 255x60x15.
Cooper Cobra G/T and
Mickey Thompson Sportsman S/T. Both are a pinch higher speed rating @ 118mph. (IMHO, the Mickey's look mildly more aggressive.)
If you find a set of rims that you like in 17" and can afford the extra pennies to get them, you'll be a very happy camper with performance tires...
IF you're that type of driver. Again, if you just burble around town and aren't tearing up the streets or tracks, stick with your 15's. The BFG T/A's will be made forever because all the hotrodders use them for their show cars.
As for looks of the 15's -vs- 17's, as long as you don't go to a crazy short tire (<50), your wheels should still look relatively appropriately sized on your car.
Here is my car with my original rims (from a '79 vette), the replacement 15" rims, and my current 17" rims. Save for the white letters, aspect-wise, I think it still looks appropriate. (hover or click on the pic for fullsize)