Old thread, but I'll bite anyway.
There are 50 model years of Corvettes. And different options within each of those years. Each generation of vette is a rather different car. Better in some ways and weaker in others.
To some people, newer is always better. It's just an automatic indisputable fact of life as far as they are concerned. So the formula is 'buy the newest car you can afford'. I don't agree. There are a number of examples that clearly show that newer isn't always better... just look at the horsepower dive during the 70's for probably the most clear example ever. There are many more.
The Corvette, throughout its lifespan, has been pulled in several different directions based on all manner of pressures. The C4 has a performance 'taste' to it because the big pressure at the time was to pull up out of the weaker and weaker vettes near the end of the C3 era (due to emissions pressures). Customers wanted performance, and they got it. The C5 is pulled in a different direction because of the public's interest in a more refined less beastly and performance centric car. Which is not to say that C5's don't perform, but there's a definate different flavor to them than C4's.
The C4 is a beast. And it's meant to be. It's a very performance oriented car.
The C5 is meant to be civilized. And it loses something for that. But gains something else.
The C4 and the C5 have lost some of the taste the C3 had, too. But gained in other areas.
Etc etc etc with C1s, C2s, C3s, C4s, and C5s.
Really, my point is that you just can't figure that a higher number next to the C means 'improved in every way'. It's not. Every generation of Corvette has its own unique style and strengths that earlier and later generations do not have. Every one of them is something to be proud of.
So yeah... I roll my eyes when I watch some C5 owners look down their noses at other corvettes for being older. To me, that means that they just don't get it.
I didn't buy a 1996 LT4 CE because it was the newest car I could afford. I could have easily bought a brand new C5. But out of all the years and models available, this is the one I wanted. The other model I want is an early C3 big block... has to be black on black. I'll pick one up at some point.
But anyway... my point is... my selection of vehicle is not driven by cost, but preference. So I roll my eyes when some C5 guy assumes that I just don't have as much money as he does. Again... he just doesn't get it. (And he's totally underestimating the performance of my LT4 if he assumes he's going to leave me behind)
If you want to make the claim that all C5's are better performers than all C4's... well, I'd say you're flatly ignoring the ZR1, LT4, Grand Sport, etc. If you're comparing stock base models only, then I'd have to agree... the base model C5s just plain have more horses than the base model C4s. But beyond the base models, the comparison isn't so simple. And if you start talking about modified vettes, the comparison gets hazy real fast.
Now to be sure, I really haven't experienced much C4 bashing at all. My car gets a lot of looks and a lot of compliments... even from other sports car nuts who are nominally import only. And I'm not saying that every C5 owner 'doesn't get it' or looks down on the other generations. In fact, most of the corvette folks I've met were cool people.
Just... I guess there are two kinds of sports car enthusiasts. The kind that love a particular car (for whatever reasons) and hold all others in contempt as pieces of garbage. And the kind that love a particular car but still have respect for other cars and other people's preferences for them.
I wish there were more of the latter. I mean... the only people that hate my car are sports car enthusiasts for other cars. The general public thinks my car is dandy. What is it that makes a sports car nut hate so many sports cars? I mean... think about it. The general public doesn't care about bitter rivalries or minor performance differences between these cars. They think they're all nice. It's only sports car enthusiasts that get into mud slinging. Ain't that wacky?
Personally, I think there's a lot of respectable Japanese and European and whatever sports cars out there, too. They're not to my preference... I'll always be a vette guy. But I do think that all of these cars are just plain cool. And I respect each of them for their unique strengths.
I wish everyone did. Especially victims of the 'All American cars suck' mantra. You know... the ones that don't even know anything about the cars they're bashing... just repeating what they've 'heard'... just like the people they heard it from...
- Skant